When it Comes to Addiction, What is the Best Path to Recovery - Abstinence or Harm Reduction?
Posted September 24, 2019 by Renee Fierro, LPCCs, Director, Outpatient Behavioral Health Services
Addiction recovery is a deeply personal journey, and different strategies work for different people. The two most common, and very different, recovery philosophies are abstinence and harm reduction. The following is a brief description of each of these approaches.
Abstinence
Abstinence-based recovery dates back centuries, long before addiction was determined to be a medical disease. This recovery philosophy expects an individual to completely stop the use of alcohol and other drugs as part of the treatment process.The concept of abstinence is connected to the Alcoholics Anonymous (AA) model that utilizes complete abstinence as a cornerstone of their program. AA principles include the concepts of powerlessness, spirituality and family involvement as a foundation of its program.For many years, addiction treatment programs worked (and many still do) hand-in-hand with AA and other 12 step programs, often requiring attendance at meetings as a component of treatment.Someone following this recovery philosophy would be expected to completely stay away from using any, and all, mind-altering substances.
Abstinence-based addiction treatment is predicated on the idea that there is no “safe” amount of drinking or drug use for people in recovery.Addiction is viewed as a condition that can’t be cured and relapse is always a possibility.Individuals often participate in individual and group therapy as a component of treatment.There is a strong emphasis on community support and AA or NA (Narcotics Anonymous) meeting attendance is highly recommended, if not required.Often times, an abstinence program will also include physical, social and spiritual wellness components, like adding in regular workouts or joining a church. The idea is that this program will replace a person’s “bad habits” with more positive activities.
One of the biggest criticisms of abstinence treatment is that it is often based in faith, and not all people are comfortable with the idea of focusing on spirituality. Opponents also point out the rigidity of these programs that will discharge people from treatment if abstinence is not maintained, or meeting attendance does not occur. This seems to be in contrast with the understanding of addiction that relapse is often a part of the recovery process. Abstinence-based programs often have an expected recovery process made to fit all, as opposed to individualized treatment that meets people where they need to be met as they traverse recovery.
Harm Reduction
Harm reduction, on the other hand, is a philosophy that focuses on educating people about safer substance use when an individual is not ready to commit to abstinence. The harm reduction philosophy accepts the existence of substance use, and rather than punishing (discharging) people who use drugs, the approach focuses on minimizing the harmful consequences of substance use by educating people about safer consumption methods.
Harm reduction was first popularized in the 1980s in Europe when government officials were searching for ways to combat the growing HIV epidemic. This resulted in the development of needle exchange programs and methadone treatment for opiate addiction. Rather than condemning people who use drugs, the harm reduction method says that we should put time and energy toward minimizing the harmful consequences of users’ actions. More recently, the opioid epidemic, that includes a significant increase in overdose deaths in the U.S., has led to an increase in Medication Assisted Therapies (MAT).MAT is a harm reduction treatment model for opiate and alcohol addiction that offers the possibility to greatly reduce overdose deaths.
Safety is the first step of harm reduction, focused on controlling the situation when drugs are being used. Some examples of this focus include: not drinking or using drugs while driving; preventing overdoses including being aware of the signs of an overdose and having naloxone on hand to be able to administer if necessary;testing drugs for Fentanyl by using testing strips before using a drug; and, reducing the transmission of diseases through dirty needles.
The second step of someone following the harm reduction model is to focus on decreasing the amount/frequency of alcohol or drug consumption. This piece of harm reduction focuses on self-accountability along with peer support and utilizes meetings and online services.
One of the biggest criticisms of the harm reduction philosophy is that it relies on people being honest with their peers and themselves. It is not uncommon for a person to lie about how much they are consuming. It is the individual’s responsibility to be aware and maintain their own path. The harm reduction method is also highly criticized because it doesn’t help prevent people from using illegal drugs and it doesn’t educate patients on how to manage their pain without the use of drugs.
What’s Best?
The best treatment philosophy is still under debate in the treatment and recovery community.It is fully dependent on the individual’s needs and is the one that the person will stick to in the long run. It’s important for someone who is looking to treat drug or alcohol addiction to meet with a behavioral therapist/counselor to identify their individualized needs.Even if an individual is not ready for complete abstinence, the harm reduction methodology is a good start in getting help and making positive changes that can lead to safer and healthier choices.
Summa Health has various addiction treatment programs available, including the First Step Opiate Addiction Treatment Program and the Addiction Medicine Intensive Outpatient Program. Take the first step and contact us today to make an appointment.
About the Author
Vitality eNews Sign Up
Receive the Summa Health eNewsletter for the latest health tips, advice and updates.
Related Blogs
New Year’s resolutions are a fun tradition to ring in the new year and celebrate a fresh start. If you’ve already made a list of goals for 2025, no doubt losing weight, eating healthier and exercising more top your list.
But did you know cutting back or even giving up alcohol altogether can help you achieve all of these health goals and more in one resolution? It’s true! Going dry for 30 days or more does more than just save you money, it also can bring…
In this episode, we delve into the often unspoken reality of pregnancy and infant loss. We discuss the importance of communication and combating the stigma surrounding these sensitive topics.
We also explore the importance of offering support to those in your life experiencing this loss and how you can give that support.
Please be advised that this podcast does not replace professional medical or mental health guidance. If you have concerns about your pregnancy or mental well-being, prioritize consulting a qualified healthcare professional.
Join us as we navigate these sensitive issues with respect and a focus on creating supportive communities. Thank you for listening.
The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services reports an estimated 46 million people in this country, aged 12 and older, suffer from substance use disorder. Unfortunately, that number continues to rise, as the COVID-19 pandemic has exacerbated the crisis.
Addiction is a chronic brain disease characterized by continued use of drugs or alcohol despite harmful consequences. Continued use of addictive substances triggers the release of chemicals, which alter the brain&…
This time of year, it feels like our world is gray and gloomy, bright sunshine will never reappear and the cold winds dampen our spirits at every turn. It’s easy to experience the winter blues.
But, for some people winter is quite literally depressing. Seasonal Affective Disorder (SAD) is a type of depression that comes and goes with the seasons, typically starting in the late fall and early winter and going away during the spring and summer.
As the days become short and…
Does someone you love have an addiction? You’re not alone. The U.S. Department of Health and Human Services reports an estimated 46 million people in this country, aged 12 and older, suffer from substance use disorder.
Addiction, or substance use disorder, is a chronic brain disease characterized by continued use of drugs or alcohol despite its harmful consequences to the person’s health and well-being. Continued use of addictive substances triggers the release of…
You’ve probably heard the term “behavioral health,” but what exactly does it mean? Behavioral Health refers to the emotions and behaviors that affect your overall well-being, and encompasses mental health and substance use disorders, along with their stress-related physical symptoms. Behavioral health conditions can include depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, anger management, drinking or drug abuse, traumatic stress and much more.
Because many people…
According to the most recent COVID-19 Practitioner Survey conducted by the American Psychological Association, more psychologists reported an increased demand for mental health services in 2021 compared to 2020, with the most significant treatment increases occurring for those suffering from anxiety, depression and trauma-related disorders.
As your community healthcare partner, Summa Health is deeply committed to offering the highest quality behavioral health services to you…
In recent months, international conflicts, COVID, and violence have impacted our lives. These disturbing events can have profound effects not only on the families and communities where they occur but also on parents and children many miles from the scene.
Tragedies like these often shake our sense of trust and security. They feel personal because these are everyday people doing everyday things. Our kids go to school, we shop at grocery stores, attend concerts and movies, and…
Updated April 2025
As humans, we strive to achieve a sense of belonging, acceptance and connection with others. These innate needs and desires often originate from family. Through these interactions, we gain a sense of self-worth, security and community. Families, regardless of blood relation or choice, are bound together by shared meaning and values. These beliefs and perspectives shape the realities that form these connections, but what happens to a family when trauma alters…
The stress of the COVID-19 pandemic has taken a toll on everyone, but especially on those who have battled the virus and now have lingering symptoms.
Known as “long COVID-19” or “post-COVID syndrome,” some patients are experiencing COVID-19 symptoms for weeks or even months after recovering from the acute phase of infection — even when the virus is no longer detected in their bodies. Even patients who had mild cases and weren’t hospitalized…
Updated September 2024
Just as our bodies require care and exercise over the course of our life, so do our brains — especially as we age. Lifting weights strengthens our muscles, while strengthening our mental “muscles” improves our memory, attention, brain speed, people skills, intelligence and navigation.
The key is variety. Similarly when we exercise our body, if doing something becomes too easy, it’s time to make a change to build brainpower. The…
Stress is inevitable and a natural part of our modern lives. Bills come every month, kids’ activities are year-round and work never seems to slow down.
Suffice it to say, stress is something all of us struggle with at times. However, it’s one that all of us cope with differently — some in healthy ways and others in unhealthy ways. Some people may turn to meditation or a friend to release stressful energy, while others may turn to more harmful activities or…
Stress is a natural part of our modern lives. Bills come every month, kids’ activities are year-round and work never seems to slow down. A little bit of stress is inevitable, but oftentimes that’s a good thing.
Stress helps you meet your daily challenges and motivates you to reach your goals, ultimately making you a smarter, happier and healthier person. That’s right. Good stress is vital for a healthy life.
Good vs. Bad Stress
You may think any type of stress is bad, but that…
Beautiful colors, cooler temperatures and the anticipation of the upcoming festive holidays make fall a season favorite for many.
But for those suffering from seasonal affective disorder (SAD), the shorter days with intermittent sunshine can make for a long and dreary fall and winter season — both physically and mentally.
SAD is a reoccurring type of depression that tends to have a seasonal pattern. For most, symptoms begin in late fall and can linger around until late…
Unfortunately, this is the case for many who suffer from a mental illness,…
In today’s world, we often forget to do the little things that can often make a big difference in our health and happiness. Typically, it is the simplest things that can do the most to help us feel our best every day and all year long. Here are a few tips to keep in mind for a healthier, happier day:
Make plans to do something you love. Research shows that having something to look forward to makes you happier. So, on a rough day, try to make a plan to do something…
1. Have an attitude of gratitude.
Making an effort to remember all of the things you’re grateful for is very important. Research has shown that taking time to express gratitude or even acknowledge thankfulness in our own thoughts increases well-being and creates positive feelings. Gratefulness can be the antidote to increased stressors in challenging times.
2. Spend money wisely.
Overspending, panic spending, and comfort spending can add to your stress by creating…
Laughter is what the doctor ordered when it comes to stress relief. Science shows laughter may very well be the best medicine when it comes to relieving stress — and that’s no joke. Whether you’re howling at a TV sitcom or giggling at your friend’s joke, the positive effects from laughter on body function — from increased circulation to muscle relaxation — confirm that real, sincere, happy laughter is good for you!
With April being…
Americans are often overstressed and overworked, and it’s no wonder – not all Americans have the luxury of paid time off, and even those who do generally don’t take all of it. According to research, more than one in 10 Americans say they plan to take a quarter or less of their vacation days in 2019.
There are many studies that suggest taking time off is beneficial to your mental, physical and overall health and that people who take vacations have lower stress…
While the exact cause of depression isn’t known, it is thought to be caused by an imbalance of the brain’s neurotransmitters – the chemical messengers that send signals between brain cells. While there are many effective treatments for depression, the typical approaches like therapy and antidepressants don’t necessarily work for everyone.
For decades, shock therapy, or ECT, has been used to treat major depression that was not treatable with medication and therapy. While there…
Have you ever wondered about the impact of social media on mental health? Social media has drastically changed the ways we communicate and socialize with others. In many ways, social media has had a positive impact; but the experiences can also be extremely negative, cyberbullying for example. Concerns regarding the impact of social media have resulted in a number of studies that look at the connection between social media and depression or anxiety. Not surprisingly, the…
September is designated as Suicide Prevention Awareness Month, in conjunction with Worldwide Suicide Prevention Day held on September 10. Events held on this day focus on raising awareness that suicide IS preventable, providing education and information about suicide, and decreasing the stigma associated with suicide.
Despite these (and other) efforts, suicide statistics tell a grim story. Just to cite a few examples, suicide rates have been on the rise since 1999.…
June 27th is PTSD Awareness Day (and all of June is PTSD Awareness Month). PTSD, or Post-traumatic Stress Disorder, is a condition that can develop following highly stressful life experiences. Some examples of these traumatic events are military combat, sexual assault, transportation accidents, and natural disasters. Such trauma exposure is quite common. Most people will experience at least one traumatic event in their lifetime.
Mental health is as complex as physical health. It can fluctuate up or down, it can be affected by genetics and physical trauma and is something that may require treatment by a medical professional.
In the US, one in five individuals is affected by a mental health condition. To address the stigma associated with mental health, discover seven myths, debunked here.